Sarah Longwell on Trump’s Transformation of the Republican Party and the American Voter
JUDJ-Prepared Summary from September 30, 2026 | How to Eat an Elephant: One Voter — and One Election — At a Time. The views and opinions expressed in this blog are those of the speaker.
In a recent America at a Crossroads discussion, Sarah Longwell, publisher of The Bulwark, host of The Focus Group podcast, and author of How to Eat an Elephant: One Voter at a Time, joined journalist Pat Morrison to examine how Donald Trump transformed the Republican Party and what years of conversations with voters reveal about American politics. Drawing on her experience as a longtime Republican strategist, Longwell explored the changing priorities of voters, the decline of traditional conservative values, and the growing divide between political insiders and everyday Americans.
From Republican Insider to Political Observer
Longwell grew up in rural Pennsylvania and entered Republican politics believing strongly in personal responsibility, character, and conservative principles. She admired leaders like John McCain and believed that integrity was essential to public service.
Trump’s rise in 2016 challenged those assumptions. Longwell initially believed Republican voters would reject his behavior and embrace a more traditional conservative alternative. But after conducting focus groups, she discovered a very different electorate.
Voters were angry, frustrated with government, and eager for someone who would challenge the political establishment. Many were willing to overlook Trump’s personal conduct because they believed he could deliver meaningful change.
The Appeal of an Unconventional Leader
Longwell explained that Trump’s political success was partly built on a public image cultivated long before he entered politics. Through decades of television appearances and The Apprentice, he established himself as a tough, decisive businessman.
For many Americans, this image mattered more than his specific policy proposals.
His promise to build a border wall, for example, resonated not necessarily because voters expected its literal completion, but because it communicated that he would take immigration seriously and challenge conventional political thinking.
Longwell observed that voters often prioritize a candidate’s perceived intentions over the details of their proposals. Trump’s willingness to disregard political norms reinforced his image as someone who could cut through government dysfunction.
When Character No Longer Counts
One of Longwell’s most striking observations concerns the Republican Party’s changing relationship with personal character.
She described a phenomenon she calls “vice signaling,” in which provocative or offensive behavior becomes a way for political figures and supporters to demonstrate allegiance to their group.
This represents a dramatic departure from the Republican Party Longwell once knew, where character and moral responsibility were central political messages.
She also identified grievance as a defining force in contemporary Republican politics, arguing that the party has become increasingly dependent on Trump’s personality rather than a consistent set of governing principles.
A Nation Divided by Information
Longwell’s research also revealed how Americans increasingly inhabit separate information environments.
She recalled conducting a focus group shortly after Trump’s controversial 2018 meeting with Vladimir Putin in Helsinki. While Washington was consumed by the controversy, participants barely knew it had happened.
For Longwell, the experience demonstrated the enormous disconnect between politically engaged Americans and ordinary voters.
Partisan media ecosystems have only deepened that divide, reinforcing existing beliefs and shaping entirely different understandings of political events.
As Republicans contemplate a future beyond Trump, Longwell believes the party faces a fundamental challenge: rediscovering an identity rooted in ideas rather than one individual. Her broader lesson is that understanding American politics begins not with assumptions about voters, but with listening to them.
About America at a Crossroads
Since April 2020, America at a Crossroads has produced weekly virtual programs on topics related to the preservation of our democracy, voting rights, freedom of the press, and a wide array of civil rights, including abortion rights, free speech, and free press. America at a Crossroads is a project of Jews United for Democracy & Justice.