Josh Rogin on Why America’s Foreign Policy Is Entering a New Era
JUDJ-Prepared Summary from June 10, 2026 | American Power at the Crossroads: Confronting China and a Fragmenting World. The views and opinions expressed in this blog are those of the speaker.
In a recent America at a Crossroads discussion, Washington Post global affairs columnist and foreign policy analyst Josh Rogin joined veteran public radio host Larry Mantle to examine the rapidly changing landscape of U.S. foreign policy. Drawing on more than two decades of reporting on international affairs, Rogin offered his perspective on the conflicts unfolding in the Middle East, the evolving role of American diplomacy, and the long-term implications of shifting relationships with allies and adversaries alike.
A Shift Away from Traditional Diplomacy
Rogin argued that America’s approach to foreign policy has fundamentally changed. Rather than relying on the traditional institutions of diplomacy, including career diplomats and the State Department, he described a system where major foreign policy decisions are increasingly centralized within the White House and driven by direct negotiations between world leaders.
According to Rogin, this transactional style of diplomacy has reduced the influence of experienced foreign policy professionals while placing greater emphasis on personal relationships and dealmaking. He suggested this shift has altered how allies and adversaries alike engage with the United States.
Iran Highlights the Challenges
Much of the conversation focused on the ongoing conflict involving Iran. Rogin characterized the situation as a strategic stalemate, arguing that neither military escalation nor maintaining the current status quo offers a clear path forward.
He described competing viewpoints within the administration, with one faction advocating for increased military pressure while another favors pursuing a negotiated settlement. Rogin maintained that diplomacy ultimately remains the only realistic long-term solution, although he acknowledged both sides remain far apart in their negotiating positions.
The Importance of America's Alliances
Beyond the Middle East, Rogin expressed concern about the future of America’s relationships with longstanding allies. He discussed growing tensions with NATO partners, Canada, and several democratic nations that have historically worked closely with the United States.
Rogin warned that rebuilding trust after periods of uncertainty is often far more difficult than damaging it. As countries adapt their own foreign and economic policies, strategic changes made today could have consequences that extend well beyond a single presidential administration.
Looking Beyond Today's Headlines
While current conflicts dominate the news cycle, Rogin encouraged viewers to consider the larger strategic picture. In his view, the United States is not simply responding to individual crises but redefining how it exercises global leadership.
He concluded by emphasizing that America’s long-term influence depends not only on military strength, but also on maintaining strong alliances, investing in diplomacy, and continuing to promote democratic values. Whether future leaders choose to reinforce or reshape those priorities, the decisions made today will help determine America’s place in the world for years to come.
About America at a Crossroads
Since April 2020, America at a Crossroads has produced weekly virtual programs on topics related to the preservation of our democracy, voting rights, freedom of the press, and a wide array of civil rights, including abortion rights, free speech, and free press. America at a Crossroads is a project of Jews United for Democracy & Justice.